← Q&A and Video Feedback Call ReplaysAll programsHomeSearch
Q&A and Video Feedback Call Replays·Q&A Recordings·34:53

Q&A, 25 Apr 2024: ND/PL Over CPL, ND64-128 for Snow and Sand, the Eclipse Filter Nobody Should Try, Resolve's Appetite for GPUs, Customs and Common Sense Abroad, Which Drones to Pack, FPV Nausea, and Jonathan's Rough Cut

John Meyer Instructor - host; new Avata 2 owner · Paul (student, West Virginia) Mavic 3 Pro + Mini 4 Pro; St. Lucia trip; PC upgraded for Resolve - not Paul Berg · Jonathan Student (absent) - East Bay Township rough cut reviewed

The short version

  1. Plain CPLs rarely - the polarising angle changes with heading and can't be adjusted in flight; ND/PL combos instead. Night: NDs off; snow and white sand: ND64, sometimes ND128; in a hurry, no ND and motion blur in post. Eclipse: an ND2000 'wasn't strong enough and could melt the sensor' - ND100,000 territory - so the hyperlapse was scrapped.
  2. Shoot 30-90-second discrete clips, not one long roll - 'much easier to edit.' Resolve wants a GPU (the student needed 12 GB, an 850 W supply and a modified case); the 'make Resolve faster' lesson is the answer on modest hardware. Abroad: Europe was painless with EU registration and ~$5 insurance; St. Lucia never answered - fly cautiously, early, away from people, Part 107 habits as the baseline.
  3. Travel kit: sub-250 g used to be the only drone he packed in Europe; now an Air 3 or Mavic 3 plus an FPV. FPV goggles made the student sick for hours; John never has been. Handheld: Canon R6 Mk II on a gimbal; the student's Galaxy S24 with clip-on Freewell NDs on an Osmo mount. Jonathan's cut: smooth push-ins and pull-outs, but smooth the ramps, lift trees and pull highlights, one shot 'still in log', cut the flat sky, fewer fast pans, a bigger ending reveal.

At a glance, three clicks deep

Skim here first: the closed row is the glance, open is the study card with the key points and timestamps, and the ↓ link drops to that concept's full write-up below.

01Filters: ND/PL over CPL, ND64-128 in bright scenes, and the eclipse lessonND/PL not CPL;

ND/PL not CPL; off at night; 64-128 for snow/sand; never point a drone at the sun.

CPL vs ND/PL (Lbaf83465 0:02-0:04)

Strengths and the eclipse (Lbaf83465 0:03-0:07)

↓ Full write-up of this concept

02Short clips, Resolve hardware, customs abroad, which drones to packShort takes;

Short takes; GPU for Resolve; register where required, fly discreetly; pack a main drone plus FPV.

Short clips (Lbaf83465 0:08-0:09)

Resolve hardware and the faster lesson (Lbaf83465 0:09-0:11)

Customs, Europe, St. Lucia (Lbaf83465 0:13-0:18)

Which drones; FPV sickness; handheld (Lbaf83465 0:18-0:24)

↓ Full write-up of this concept

03Jonathan's East Bay Township rough cutSmooth ramps, lift shadows, contrast the log shot, avoid flat sky and fast pans, bigger reveal.

Smooth ramps, lift shadows, contrast the log shot, avoid flat sky and fast pans, bigger reveal.

Praise (Lbaf83465 0:26, 0:29-0:30)

Notes (Lbaf83465 0:27-0:33)

↓ Full write-up of this concept

The concepts in full

01

Filters: ND/PL over CPL, ND64-128 in bright scenes, and the eclipse lesson

'I'll just leave the ND filter off and then add motion blur in post' - when he's in a hurry.

A polariser's correct angle depends on the sun and the drone's heading, and it can only be set on the ground - so he rarely uses plain CPLs, preferring ND/PL for the light reduction. The student's Mavic 3 Pro has an aperture; the Mini 4 Pro (like the Air 3) is fixed f/1.8. Night: NDs off for the lowest ISO; snow and sand: ND64, sometimes ND128. The student had bought an ND2000 and laser glasses for an eclipse hyperlapse, then learned it could cook the sensor and the glasses block a narrow band - abandoned.

Why it matters

Filter strength by scene, and one warning worth repeating.

02

Short clips, Resolve hardware, customs abroad, which drones to pack

'Follow standard Part 107-style practices and otherwise use common sense.'

He records discrete 30-90 s shots and stops between setups - easier to edit. The student's i7 PC needed RAM, a 12 GB GPU, an 850 W supply and case surgery for Resolve; John is on a MacBook now and points to the 'make Resolve faster' lesson. Europe: no customs trouble, EU registration and ~$5-for-5-years insurance; St. Lucia ignored an authorisation email - he doesn't believe they confiscate at customs, so fly early, away from people, 400 ft, lights at night. Packing: once only a Mini 3 Pro for Europe (sub-250 g rules); now an Air 3 or Mavic 3, plus an FPV. FPV goggles left the student nauseous for two and a half hours; John, weeks in on the Avata 2 (three-blade props, quieter), never. Handheld: Canon R6 Mk II on a gimbal; the student's Galaxy S24, clip-on Freewell NDs, Osmo-style mount, 4K30.

Why it matters

The travelling-pilot FAQ in one call.

03

Jonathan's East Bay Township rough cut

One shot 'looks kind of like it's still in log.'

Strong: smooth push-ins, pull-outs and zooms (water tower pull-away, solar-panel flyover), a composition he liked. Notes: smooth the abrupt normal-to-fast ramps; brighten trees and shadows, pull highlights for cloud detail; add contrast to the log-looking shot; cut ground footage into flat sky; fewer fast pans - a small phone gimbal for those; a faster pace ('personal preference'); continue the turn and pull-back for a bigger ending reveal; one repeated angle, an aeroplane SFX he disliked, the solar sequence wants several shots not one pan. Early cut, so glitches and grade expected to be fixed.

Why it matters

A standard-tier review with the usual notes, useful as a checklist.

Tools referenced

ToolCoverageMomentContext
DaVinci ResolvementionedGPU demands
DJI Avata 2mentionedHis new FPV
FreewellmentionedPhone clip-on NDs

Action items

    Resources mentioned

    Resources
    • docGear named

    Extraction notes

    This page was built from an auto-generated transcript, which garbles product and people's names. Those were corrected silently in everything above and logged here for transparency. The warnings flag claims that were true on the recording day but change fast.

    Transcript corrections applied

    The transcript saysThe trainer actually means
    Avada 2 / nevadaAvata 2
    free willFreewell
    Gapesburga West Virginia town - unresolved

    True on recording day — verify before relying